As the title suggests, this roaster has a lot going for it. It's very well built, and has a solid reliable feel to it. The manual is pretty helpful and the controls, once you learn them, are pretty good. I also love the fact that you can roast up to 16 oz. at a time.What I don't love. First, the auto-shutoff feature sounds great on paper. "It's a safety feature". Yeah, until you miss the timer and screw up an whole batch. This requires you to helicopter the dang thing the whole time. This 'feature' cost it an entire star.I also don't yet agree with the roast time suggestions and settings. I had to roast a batch THREE times to get the color I wanted and felt like I was guessing the whole time (and no, I don't like them burnt, but right around 1st crack). I even keep a detailed roast log and the last few entries have some four letter words in them. This is part of just figuring it out I suppose, but if you follow the instructions to the letter, the beans are not even close to being roasted.The internal light is a good idea, but it shines off the roasting drum so much you can't really see the bean color, so it's not helpful in monitoring the roast.I'm only on the first few batches so my opinion may change over time, but I doubt I'll ever like the auto-shutoff off feature.